forensic anthropology & archaeology confirm survival cannibalism in 17th-century north america

Smithsonian Institution, Colonial Williamsburg, and Preservation Virginia collaborate on groundbreaking research from Jamestown, Va.

May 1, 2013  Washington, D.C.   Today, the Smithsonian Institution, Colonial Williamsburg, and Preservation Virginia came together to confirm the first scientifically-proven occurrence of survival cannibalism in Colonial America. The collaboration was prompted by the archaeological discovery of a partial human skull and tibia during excavation of an early 17th-century trash deposit at Jamestown, Va. The findings date to the winter of 1609-1610 — often referred to as the “starving time” at Jamestown — when sickness, starvation and Indian attacks led to the deaths of more than 200 men, women, and children crowded into James Fort. The forensic evidence confirms a desperate battle for survival. While several written accounts of survival cannibalism in the American colonies exist, this is the first time that cannibalism has been proven by forensic evidence.

“Our team has discovered partial human remains before, but the location of the discovery, visible damage to the skull and marks on the bones immediately made us realize this finding was unusual,” said Dr. Bill Kelso, chief archaeologist of the Jamestown Rediscovery Project who has been overseeing excavations at Jamestown for more than 20 years. “We approached the Smithsonian’s National Museum of Natural History for further research because of their proven understanding of the contextual history in this part of Virginia.”

Dr. Douglas Owsley, Division Head of Physical Anthropology at the museum, identified chops to the forehead and back of the cranium to open the head; knife cuts on the jaw and cheek indicating removal of the flesh; and markings indicating the head’s left side was punctured and pried apart: all physical evidence consistent with survival cannibalism. Further investigation of the remains allowed Dr. Owsley to determine the subject’s sex, age, ancestry, and status. The shape of the skull and size of the tibia indicate the remains are female. Examination of molar development and the growth stage of the joint below the knee indicate that she was about 14 years old. Isotopic testing found she had consumed a European diet of wheat and meat, while oxygen levels and skull shape reiterated her country of origin.

The research team has named her “Jane.” Her identity is unknown, and although DNA samples have been saved for future examination, there is little hope of identifying modern relatives for comparative testing.

Based on the anthropological evidence of her diet and the archaeological layer where her partial remains were found, researchers believe “Jane” arrived in Jamestown in August 1609, just months before the worst of the “starving time.”

“The ‘starving time’ was brought about by a trifecta of disasters: disease, a serious shortage of provisions, and a full scale siege by the Powhatans that cut off Jamestown from outside relief,” said Jim Horn, Colonial Williamsburg’s vice president of research and historical interpretation and an expert on Jamestown history. “Survival cannibalism was a last resort; a desperate means of prolonging life at a time when the settlement teetered on the brink of extinction.”

A new exhibition opened at The Nathalie P. and Alan M. Voorhees Archaearium at Historic Jamestowne to tell the story of “Jane” and the survival of Jamestown, England’s first permanent settlement in America.

Consuming Colonists – New York Times
Starving Settlers in Jamestown Colony Resorted to Cannibalism – Smithsonian
Skeleton of teenage girl confirms cannibalism at Jamestown colony – Washington Post
Cannibalism evidence discovered at Jamestown – Daily Press
Study: Jamestown settlers resorted to cannibalism – USA Today
Starving Jamestown Colonists Engaged in Cannibalism – Discover
Scholars Find Cannibalism at Jamestown Settlement – ABC News
Behind the scenes of Jamestown’s cannibal past – BBC News
‘Proof’ Jamestown settlers turned to cannibalism – BBC News
Reconstructing Jane – Washington Post
CSI Jamestown: Anthropologists lay out evidence of colonial cannibalism – NBC News
Evidence of survival cannibalism found in Jamestown – WTKR
Look Into The Face Of Cannibalism In Colonial Jamestown – WAMU
Evidence of Cannibalism Found at Jamestown Site – New York Times
New evidence: Starving Jamestown settlers resorted to cannibalism – Washington Times
Skeleton confirms cannibalism at Jamestown colony – UPI
British settlers in Jamestown resorted to cannibalism – The Telegraph
Excavated skull proves US settlers turned to cannibalism – The Guardian
Evidence of Cannibalism Found at Jamestown Colony – U.S. News & World Report
Starving Virginia settlers turned to cannibalism in 1609: study – Reuters
Jamestown Colonists Resorted to Cannibalism – National Geographic
Evidence Of Cannibalism At Jamestown Unearthed By Smithsonian Anthropologist – Medical Daily
Cannibalism Evidence Found at Jamestown Settlement by Scientists – Bloomberg
Bones found at Jamestown confirm cannibalism during ‘Starving Time’ – Virginia Gazette
Jamestown settlers ate 14-year-old girl, researchers say – Los Angeles Times
Jamestown Bones Show Signs of Cannibalism – AAAS
Jane Among Top Ten Archaeological Discoveries Worldwide